Taking Tea with Torturers

OpenDemocracy, January 2011

Osgoode CLPE Research Paper No. 13/2011

6 Pages Posted: 2 Feb 2011

See all articles by Craig Scott

Craig Scott

York University - Osgoode Hall Law School

Date Written: January 31, 2011


This working paper (3000 words, including 19 footnotes) was written on January 29-31, 2011, as events unfolded in Egypt. It was published in the present version as an article on January 31, 2011, by OpenDemocracy, and may be republished with attribution for non-commercial purposes following the Creative Commons guidelines. The article’s sub-title is “From the Shah of Iran to Sri Lanka’s Foreign Minister to Egypt’s Mubarak, cozy relationships in US foreign policy need to be questioned.” Its point of departure is the Thatcher-Pinochet friendship, which is related to Hillary Clinton's interview in Egypt in 2009 when she downplayed the US Department of State's own report of serious human rights violations in Egypt (including a torture apparatus) while emphasizing, "I really consider President and Mrs. Mubarak to be friends of my family." The article then shows how a version of family-ties coziness has plausibly played a role in how Sri Lanka has managed to mute, to the point of near-silence, US criticism. I take the reader through the first joint press conference held by Secretary of State Clinton and the just-appointed Foreign Minister of Sri Lanka G L Peiris, who attended Oxford University as a Rhodes Scholar alongside former US President Bill Clinton. Amongst the notable omissions and elisions in Hillary Clinton’s remarks during that press conference was the complete failure to address her own Department of State’s report on approximately 300 incidents of possible war crimes in Sri Lanka that needed investigating. I return to Egypt in its present crisis by comparing the 30 years of support for Mubarak to the decades of US support for the Shah of Iran, which support then merged with President Jimmy Carter's inability to disentangle a personal rapport with the Shah from Carter's supposed human rights-friendly foreign policy. The piece ends with consideration of the implications for US foreign policy of cozy personal relationships with key politicians in repressive regimes – implications that go beyond adding a layer of complexity, extending to questions of ethical accountability.

Keywords: Ethics, Political Accountability, Realpolitik, Foreign Policy, Human Rights, Torture, Democracy, International Politics, Hillary Rodham Clinton, United States, Sri Lanka, Egypt, Shah Of Iran, Augusto Pinochet, Margaret Thatcher, Hosni Mubarak, G L Peiris, Jimmy Carter, Barak Obama

Suggested Citation

Scott, Craig M., Taking Tea with Torturers (January 31, 2011). OpenDemocracy, January 2011; Osgoode CLPE Research Paper No. 13/2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1752889

Craig M. Scott (Contact Author)

York University - Osgoode Hall Law School ( email )


HOME PAGE: http://craigscott.ndp.ca

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics