Abstract Principles and Concrete Cases in Intuitive Lawmaking
46 Pages Posted: 8 Feb 2011
Date Written: February 5, 2011
Abstract
Citizens awaiting jury service were asked a series of items, in Likert format, to determine their endorsement of various statements about principles to use in setting child support amounts. These twenty items were derived from extant child support systems, from past literature and from Ellman and Ellman’s (2008) Theory of Child Support. The twenty items were found to coalesce into four factors (principles). There were pervasive gender differences in respondent’s endorsement of the principles. More importantly, three of these four principles were systematically reflected, in very rational (if complex) ways, in the respondents’ resolution of the individual child support cases they were asked to decide. Differences among respondents in their endorsement of these three principles accounted for differences in their patterns of child support judgments. It is suggested that the pattern of coherent arbitrariness (Ariely, Loewenstein, & Prelec, 2003) in those support judgments, noted in an earlier study (Ellman, Braver, and MacCoun 2009) is thus partially explained, in that the seeming arbitrariness of respondents’ initial support judgments reflect in part their differing views about the basic principles that should decide the cases.
Keywords: child support, decisionmaking, judgments
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Intuitive Lawmaking: The Example of Child Support
By Ira Mark Ellman, Sanford L. Braver, ...
-
Intuitive Lawmaking: The Example of Child Support
By Ira Mark Ellman, Sanford L. Braver, ...
-
By Ira Mark Ellman and Tara Ellman
-
Fudging Failure: The Economic Analysis Used to Construct Child Support Guidelines
-
By Sanford L. Braver, Robert Maccoun, ...
-
Brigitte M. Bodenheimer Memorial Lecture on the Family: Inventing Family Law
-
Lay Intuitions About Family Obligations: The Case of Alimony
By Ira Mark Ellman and Sanford L. Braver
-
Lay Judgments About Child Custody After Divorce
By Sanford L. Braver, Ira Mark Ellman, ...
-
By Ira Mark Ellman and Sanford L. Braver