Conservative Accounting and Finite Firm Life: Why Residual Income Valuation Estimates Understate Stock Price
James N. Myers
University of Arkansas
August 24, 1999
Residual income (RI) valuation involves discounting estimated future RI over the entire life of the firm. Because accounting is conservative, price is higher than book value for the average firm, creating a large accounting gain (terminal income) at delisting for most firms. However, this terminal income is hidden from researchers because it is not included in archival databases such as Compustat. Although most valuation models posit infinite firm life, the median firm survives approximately ten years. Terminal income is omitted from recent archival valuation research and this omission creates biased valuation estimates. This explains why studies that use the residual income valuation model to estimate stock price understate stock price on average. The results suggest that the estimation of future price/book premiums is an important component of RI valuation and present a limitation of using accounting numbers to estimate firm value without reference to price.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 30
JEL Classification: G12, G31, G32, M41
Date posted: October 25, 1999