The Lawyer’s Perspective: The Gap Between Individual Decisions and Collective Consequences in Legal Ethics

Posted: 13 Mar 2011 Last revised: 11 Jan 2017

Andrew B. Ayers

Albany Law School

Date Written: 2011

Abstract

Legal ethicists often make arguments about what will happen if lawyers in general behave in a certain way. They sometimes assume that these arguments about the collective consequences of lawyers’ actions can help individual lawyers decide what they have most reason to do. But collective consequences are not necessarily reasons for individual lawyers to choose one action over another.

To understand why arguments from collective consequences sometimes fail, it is important to understand two ways of looking at legal ethics. The first is the policy-maker’s perspective. Policy-makers are necessarily concerned with collective consequences, because legal rules and social norms operate generally. But individual practitioners do not make decisions about what lawyers collectively will do. And they often know that their individual choices will not have any real impact on collective goods. For example, society generally may depend on lawyers to make sure that unpopular views are represented in court. But my individual decision to turn away an unpopular client will not undermine that value.

One solution to this problem is for lawyers to find intrinsic value in the kinds of actions which, in the aggregate, promote good consequences. Legal ethicists should aim to help lawyers understand how it can be intrinsically valuable for them to act in certain ways even when their individual choices will not affect collective goods. But intrinsic value can be understood only from the lawyer’s perspective.

Keywords: legal ethics, intrinsic value

Suggested Citation

Ayers, Andrew B., The Lawyer’s Perspective: The Gap Between Individual Decisions and Collective Consequences in Legal Ethics (2011). 36 J. Legal Prof. 77 (2011). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1783073

Andrew B. Ayers (Contact Author)

Albany Law School ( email )

80 New Scotland Avenue
Albany, NY 12208
United States

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
407