Do Judges Vary in Their Treatment of Race?
39 Pages Posted: 2 Apr 2011 Last revised: 28 Sep 2013
Date Written: May 28, 2013
Abstract
Are minorities treated differently by the legal system? Systematic racial differences in case characteristics, many unobservable, make this a difficult question to answer directly. In this paper, we estimate whether judges differ from each other in how they sentence minorities, avoiding potential bias from unobservable case characteristics by exploiting the random assignment of cases to judges. We measure the between-judge variation in the difference in incarceration rates and sentence lengths between African-American and White defendants. We perform a Monte Carlo simulation in order to explicitly construct the appropriate counterfactual, where race does not influence judicial sentencing. In our data set, which includes felony cases from Cook County, Illinois, we find statistically significant between-judge variation in incarceration rates, although not in sentence lengths.
Keywords: Criminal law, racial discrimination, race and justice, punishment, sentencing, bias, incarceration rate, sentence length, Monte Carlo simulation, empirical research, forecasting and simulation, accounting for disparities in judicial behavior, law and economics of crime
JEL Classification: C79, J29, J71, K14
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
The Impact of Race on Policing, Arrest Patterns, and Crime
By John J. Donohue and Steven D. Levitt
-
The Impact of Race on Policing, Arrest Patterns, and Crime
By John J. Donohue and Steven D. Levitt
-
Racial Discrimination Among NBA Referees
By Joseph Price and Justin Wolfers
-
Racial Discrimination Among NBA Referees
By Joseph Price and Justin Wolfers
-
Charity and Favoritism in the Field: Are Female Economists Nicer (to Each Other)?
-
How Much Trouble is Early Foul Trouble? Strategically Idling Resources in the NBA
By Allan Maymin, Philip Maymin, ...
-
Employer Information Report (EEO-1): Data Overview
By Ronald Edwards, Bliss Cartwright, ...