Clear Rules - Not Necessarily Simple or Accessible Ones

Virginia Law Review In Brief, Vol. 97, pp. 13-22, May 2011

10 Pages Posted: 3 May 2011

See all articles by Lumen N. Mulligan

Lumen N. Mulligan

University of Missouri Kansas City

Date Written: May 2, 2011

Abstract

In The Complexity of Jurisdictional Clarity, 97 VA. L. REV. 1 (2011), Professor Dodson argues that the traditional call for clear and simple rules über alles in subject matter jurisdiction is misplaced. In this response essay, I begin by arguing that Dodson, while offering many valuable insights, does not adequately distinguish between the separate notions of simplicity, clarity, and accessibility. Second, I note that crafting a clarity enhancing rule, even if complex and inaccessible, may be a more promising endeavor than the search for a regime that is at once clear, simple and accessible. In the third section, I contend that a focus on clarity in isolation, in lieu of simplicity or accessibility, both furthers Dodson’s project of illustrating that the value of clarity is often a false idol and reveals the inherently empirical nature of the question. I close by noting that although Dodson’s piece importantly demonstrates that jurisdictional clarity comes at a cost, his inability to resolve these underlying empirical questions makes it unlikely that he will quiet those advocating clarity-based jurisdictional reform.

Keywords: jurisdiction, subject matter jurisdiction, jurisdictional rules, federal courts, civil procedure, legal reform, legal complexity

Suggested Citation

Mulligan, Lumen N., Clear Rules - Not Necessarily Simple or Accessible Ones (May 2, 2011). Virginia Law Review In Brief, Vol. 97, pp. 13-22, May 2011, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1829562 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1829562

Lumen N. Mulligan (Contact Author)

University of Missouri Kansas City ( email )

500 E. 52nd Street
Kansas City, MO 64110
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
92
Abstract Views
1,236
Rank
497,282
PlumX Metrics