Structuring Knowledge Retrieval: An Analysis of Decomposed Quantitative Judgments
21 Pages Posted: 3 Jun 2011
Date Written: January 1, 1987
Abstract
Subjects were asked to estimate the answers to 16 questions concerning uncertain quantities like, "How many people are employed by hospitals in the U.S.?" under five different aiding conditions. The most-aided group (Full Algorithm) was given a complete algorithm and asked to make estimates for the parts of the algorithm and to combine the parts as indicated to arrive at an estimate of the desired quantity. The second group (Partial Algorithm) was given the same algorithm without indications of how to combine the parts. After making estimates of the parts, these subjects then estimated the desired quantity. The third group (List & Estimate) was asked to list components or factors they thought were relevant, make an estimate of each item on their list, and then estimate the desired quantity. The fourth group (List) was asked to make such a list, but they were not asked to make estimates of each item before making an estimate of the desired quantity. The fifth group received no aid. The results generally showed improved performance in terms of both accuracy and consistency across subjects with increasing structure of the aid. Generalization of these results to practical estimation situations is possible but limited by the need, in real situations, for the estimator to develop the algorithm, a task that was done here by the experimenters.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
By Fred Collopy and J. Scott Armstrong
-
Error Measures for Generalizing About Forecasting Methods: Empirical Comparisons
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy
-
By J. Scott Armstrong and Robert Carbone
-
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy
-
Causal Forces: Structuring Knowledge for Time-Series Extrapolation
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy
-
Expert Opinions About Extrapolation and the Mystery of the Overlooked Discontinuities
By Fred Collopy and J. Scott Armstrong
-
Beyond Accuracy: Comparison of Criteria Used to Select Forecasting Methods
By Thomas Yokum and J. Scott Armstrong
-
Identification of Asymmetric Prediction Intervals Through Causal Forces
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy