Why Can’t We All Just Get Along: Structural Modeling and Natural Experiments in Merger Analysis
48 Pages Posted: 31 May 2011 Last revised: 17 Nov 2011
Date Written: November 17, 2011
Abstract
Economists have two basic methodologies: structuralism, in which formal economic models control the analysis, and experimentalism, in which economic theory guides the analysis, but data from experiments determines the policy recommendation. The choice between the two approaches is often quite controversial, although each approach has its own strengths and limitations. Under either approach, the scientific method requires testing and, when choosing between models with comparable empirical support, verification. We describe how these approaches play out in merger analysis; where Cournot and Bertrand models of competition are the standard Structuralist tools. In contrast, Experimentalists generally search for some type of evidence of a relationship between structure and market performance. Which methodology is superior for merger analysis depends first on empirical testing of the relevant theories and then on how closely the facts of the market match the assumptions of the relevant economic theory and how much precision the analysis requires to generate a useful conclusion. We illustrate these tradeoffs with examples from three recently-litigated cases.
Keywords: Structural Models, Natural Experiments, Merger Policy, Falsification, Identification
JEL Classification: B41, K21, L40
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Daubert, Science, and Modern Game Theory: Implications for Merger Analysis
-
Unilateral Effects Under the Guidelines: Models, Merits, and Merger Policy
-
Upward Pressure on Price (UPP) Analysis: Issues and Implications For Merger Policy
By Joseph J. Simons and Malcolm B. Coate
-
By Gregory K. Leonard and Lawrence Wu
-
The Enhanced Upward Pressure on Price Screen: Merging Markets into the UPP Methodology
-
Continuity and Change in the 2010 Merger Guidelines
By Malcolm B. Coate and Joseph J. Simons
-
Critical Loss: Modeling and Application Issues
By Malcolm B. Coate and Joseph J. Simons