Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

A Sentence-Based Theory of Complementarity

Harvard International Law Journal, Vol. 53, No. 1, Winter 2012

Ashgate Research Companion to International Criminal Law: Critical Perspectives, 2012

50 Pages Posted: 3 Jun 2011 Last revised: 15 Apr 2012

Kevin Jon Heller

University of Amsterdam; University of London - School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS)

Date Written: 2011

Abstract

Scholars have long debated to what extent the Rome Statute’s principle of complementarity permits states to prosecute war crimes, crimes against humanity, and acts of genocide as ordinary crimes such as rape and murder instead of as international crimes. Two positions dominate the discourse, what I call the “hard mirror thesis” and the “soft mirror thesis.” Proponents of the hard mirror thesis argue that such prosecutions never satisfy the principle of complementarity, because the mere act of prosecuting an international crime as an ordinary crime indicates that the state is unwilling or unable to genuinely prosecute. Proponents of the soft mirror thesis, by contrast, accept that prosecuting an international crime as an ordinary crime does not necessarily mean that the state is unwilling or unable to prosecute, but nevertheless insist that states should prosecute international crimes as international crimes whenever possible, because such prosecutions better serve the goals of the Rome Statute. I challenge both theses in the essay and defend an alternative theory of complementarity that focuses exclusively on sentence. In particular, I argue that any national prosecution of an ordinary crime should satisfy the principle of complementarity as long as it results in a sentence equal to, or longer than, the sentence the perpetrator would receive from the ICC.

Keywords: ICC, International Criminal Court, complementarity, international crimes, Article 17, primacy

Suggested Citation

Heller, Kevin Jon, A Sentence-Based Theory of Complementarity (2011). Harvard International Law Journal, Vol. 53, No. 1, Winter 2012. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1857428

Kevin Jon Heller (Contact Author)

University of Amsterdam ( email )

Amsterdam, 1018 WB
Netherlands

University of London - School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS) ( email )

Thornhaugh Street
Russell Square: College Buildings 541
London, WC1H 0XG
United Kingdom

Paper statistics

Downloads
542
Rank
41,502
Abstract Views
2,779