Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

The Incautious Media, Free Speech, and the Unfair Trial: Why Prosecutors Need More Realistic Guidance in Dealing with the Press

36 Pages Posted: 17 Jun 2011  

Andrew E. Taslitz

American University - Washington College of Law

Date Written: June 14, 2011

Abstract

The ABA has proposed a new Standard for the Prosecution Function, Standard 3-1.7, which addresses how prosecutors should communicate with the media. The core portion of that proposal prohibits a prosecutor from making a statement raising a substantial risk of materially prejudicing a criminal proceeding or of unnecessarily heightening public condemnation of the accused. But this proposal is unrealistic. Recent findings in cognitive science suggest that media information overload and its fast pace result in media coverage of high-profile trials that heightens audience's negative emotions while compromising their critical faculties. Audience members thus are enraged at accused offenders and ill-equipped to judge the accuracy and completeness of media crime stories. All media in such cases therefore raise the substantial risks that the proposal prohibits. On the other hand, prosecutors' commentary to the press serves important free speech and political purposes, which this Article details. This Article weighs this balance to come up with an alternative series of guiding ethical principles, including, centrally, the principle that the prosecutor's statements shall not aggravate the unavoidable risks to trial fairness. The remaining principles detail how to give this non-aggravation rule greater specificity in channeling prosecutors' ethical decision making in communicating with the media.

Keywords: free speech, fair trial, First Amendment, media, cognitive bias, self-rule, autonomy, empathy, condemnation, stigma, technology, status, group, ABA Standards, net-reading, jury, stigma, morality play, governing, voice

JEL Classification: J70, Z00

Suggested Citation

Taslitz, Andrew E., The Incautious Media, Free Speech, and the Unfair Trial: Why Prosecutors Need More Realistic Guidance in Dealing with the Press (June 14, 2011). Hastings Law Journal, Vol. 62, No. 5, 2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1864823

Andrew E. Taslitz (Contact Author)

American University - Washington College of Law ( email )

4300 Nebraska Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20016
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
156
Rank
160,434
Abstract Views
976