Power, Paradigms, and Legal Prescriptions: 'The Rule of Law' as a Necessary but Not Sufficient Condition for Transitional Justice

32 Pages Posted: 21 Jul 2011  

Meredith Render

University of Alabama - School of Law

Date Written: July 20, 2011

Abstract

This essay considers the various ways that law functions to sometimes perpetuate and sometimes prevent genocide and other mass catastrophes in transitional societies. In particular, the essay examines three conceptually distinct aspects of law within a given society - the concept of law, the “rule of law” and the role (or function) of law - and posits that only by considering the interplay of these three aspects of law within transitional societies can we fully appreciate the necessity of a robust commitment to the rule of law as a bulwark against mass atrocity within transitional societies.

The essay offers a response and supplement to the insights contained in David Gray’s interesting essay, "Transitional Disclosures: What Transitional Justice Reveals about Law” in which Gray thoughtfully challenges the conventional view that a commitment to the rule of law is the sole and best hope for preventing mass atrocity given the role that “law” and legal officials often play in perpetuating mass violence, and contends that dynamic stability among competing and overlapping identities (i.e. religious, ethnic, class) and associations is necessary to stave off abusive regimes. While this essay accepts the latter insight, I argue that Gray’s multi-dimensional “law as paradigm” understanding of the relationship between legal institutions and abusive norms obscures important distinctions between the concept of law, the rule of law, and the role of law. By retracing these distinctions, the essay demonstrates that a robust commitment to the rule of law is indeed a necessary (but not sufficient) condition for preventing the rise of abusive regimes, even within Gray’s own prescription.

Keywords: Transitional justice, rule of law, David Gray, genocide, identity

Suggested Citation

Render, Meredith, Power, Paradigms, and Legal Prescriptions: 'The Rule of Law' as a Necessary but Not Sufficient Condition for Transitional Justice (July 20, 2011). TRANSITIONS, Austin Sarat, ed., 2011; University of Alabama Public Law Research Paper No. 1890688. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1890688

Meredith Render (Contact Author)

University of Alabama - School of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 870382
Tuscaloosa, AL 35487
United States
205-348-4347 (Phone)
205-348-5829 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.law.ua.edu/directory/view.php?user=356

Paper statistics

Downloads
194
Rank
128,354
Abstract Views
1,681