An Empirical Study on the Determinants of Essential Patent Claims in Compatibility Standards
28 Pages Posted: 30 Jul 2011
Date Written: July 30, 2011
Abstract
In the field of compatibility standards, an increasing number of companies claim to own so-called essential patents (i.e. those patents that are indispensable for designing and manufacturing products conforming to the standard). It is widely believed that the ownership of such patents is a very valuable bargaining tool in cross-license negotiations, while for non-producing firms such patents may result in a substantial stream of licensing revenues. In this paper we study the determinants of essential patent claims in compatibility standards. In particular, we assess the role of two main factors: the significance of the technological solution contained in the patent and the involvement of the applicant of the patent in the standardisation process. We examine the case of W CDMA, one of the most successful standards in mobile telecommunications. We compare the patents claimed essential for this standard with a control group of randomly selected, unclaimed patents covering the same time period and technology classes. We find empirical evidence that both factors have significant impact on the probability that a patent is claimed as essential, but the involvement in the standardisation process is a stronger determinant than the technical value (‘merit’) of the patent. On the basis of our findings, we offer policy recommendations.
Keywords: Essential patents, Compatibility standards, IPR policies, Mobile telecommunications, W-CDMA, Economics of information systems
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Sequential Bargaining Without a Common Prior on the Recognition Process
-
Choosing the Rules for Consensus Standardization
By Joseph Farrell and Timothy Simcoe
-
By Henry S. Farber and Max H. Bazerman
-
Waiting to Settle: Multilateral Bargaining with Subjective Biases
-
Innovating Standards Through Informal Consortia: The Case of Wireless Telecommunications
By Henry Delcamp and Aija E. Leiponen
-
Attributes and Dynamic Development Phases of Informal ICT Standards Consortia
-
By David Goldreich and Lukasz Pomorski