Alternative Approaches to Factual Causation in Cases Involving Gradual-Onset Psychiatric Diseases in the Workplace

Journal of Contemporary Roman-Dutch Law, Vol. 73, p. 531, 2010

22 Pages Posted: 5 Aug 2011

See all articles by Meryl Du Plessis

Meryl Du Plessis

University of Cape Town, Department of Public Law

Date Written: August 5, 2010

Abstract

The law often requires that we make definitive pronouncements, even in the absence of definitive proof. Standards and burdens of proof have been developed to take into account this reality, but in an increasingly technical and complicated world, our approach to determining causes has to change. In cases of workplace psychiatric harm, both the law of delict and workers’ compensation law require a relationship between the impugned act of the wrongdoer or the occupational disease, on the one hand, and the harm suffered by the victim on the other. In the law of delict this inquiry has traditionally been divided into “factual causation” and “legal causation” and this distinction remains relevant in workers’ compensation law. While legal causation is concerned with the question of limiting liability by assessing and making value judgments as to whether liability should be imputed to a defendant, factual causation can negate liability, but is not in itself sufficient to found liability. It is therefore an exclusionary test, “allowing a court to weed out defendants without having to decide whether their conduct was legally culpable”. The article focuses on factual causation, particularly in cases of gradual-onset psychiatric harm in an occupational setting.

Keywords: Factual causation, gradual-onset psychiatric diseases

Suggested Citation

Du Plessis, Meryl, Alternative Approaches to Factual Causation in Cases Involving Gradual-Onset Psychiatric Diseases in the Workplace (August 5, 2010). Journal of Contemporary Roman-Dutch Law, Vol. 73, p. 531, 2010. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1905450

Meryl Du Plessis (Contact Author)

University of Cape Town, Department of Public Law ( email )

Private Bag X3
Rondebosch, 7701
South Africa

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
49
Abstract Views
256
PlumX Metrics