Do Managers Do Good with Other Peoples' Money?

Abstract

There is mixed evidence on whether the marginal dollar spent on corporate social responsibility
is due to agency problems. We propose an approach by modeling how the 2003 Dividend Tax Cut, which increased after-tax insider ownership and better aligned managerial and shareholder interests, affected the marginal dollar spent on firm responsibility. We confirm key predictions of our agency model: following the tax cut, moderate insider-ownership firms experience larger declines in their responsibility ratings and increases in their valuations relative to other firms. We also confirm another implication regarding managerial misalignment using a regression-discontinuity design of close votes on shareholder-governance proposals.

Keywords: ESG, CSR, agency costs

JEL Classification: G30, G31, G35