Demystifying the Art of Interpretation
European Journal of International Law, Vol. 22, No. 2, pp. 571-588, 2011
18 Pages Posted: 1 Dec 2011
Date Written: May 28, 2011
Despite its codification by the Vienna Convention more than 40 years ago, treaty interpretation in international law continues to evolve as its function of providing predictability in international relations remains as important as ever. The voluminous recent literature testifies to the continuing scholarly interest in interpretation, even if sometimes at the cost of over-theorizing. This essay reviews six books that seek to demystify the art of treaty interpretation.
Written by European scholars, the books take a fresh look at interpretation but differ in their approaches and scope of analyses. While all six authors study the interpretive practice of international courts and tribunals, Gardiner, Linderfalk and Van Damme focus on treaty interpretation; Fernández de Casadevante Romani, Kolb and Orakhelashvili also examine the interpretation of decisions by international organizations, unilateral acts and customary international law. Kolb and Orakhelashvili opt for a comprehensive, theoretically-grounded approach, whereas Van Damme focuses on the interpretative practice of the WTO Appellate Body. On the strength of her perceptive and nuanced analysis of WTO jurisprudence, the book is the best guide among the six to interpretation in international law generally. In addition to Van Damme’s work, the practitioner will also find Gardiner’s book particularly useful.
Keywords: interpretation, legal methods, international courts and tribunals, WTO, contextual and effective interpretation
JEL Classification: K33
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation