Moral Dilemmas, Collective Responsibility, and Moral Progress
Philosophical Studies, Vol. 104, pp. 203-225, 2001
26 Pages Posted: 6 Dec 2011
Date Written: November 14, 2000
Ruth Marcus has offered an account of moral dilemmas in which the presence of dilemmas acts as a motivating force, pushing us to try to minimize predicaments of moral conflict. In this paper, I defend a Marcus-style account of dilemmas against two objections: first, that if dilemmas are real, we are forced to blame those who have done their best, and second, that in some cases, even a stripped down version of blame seems inappropriate. My account highlights the importance of collective responsibility in understanding dilemmas, and I suggest that it sheds light on understanding moral progress.
Keywords: moral dilemmas, collective responsibility, moral progress, moral conflict
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation