Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Measuring Organised Crime-Related Harms: Exploring Five Policing Methods

Crime Law and Social Change, November 2011

17 Pages Posted: 1 Jan 2012  

Natasha Tusikov

Baldy Centre, State University of Buffalo (SUNY)

Date Written: October 1, 2011

Abstract

Many law enforcement agencies around the world have adapted risk assessment methodology to analyse organised crime. These assessments, which are intended to provide law enforcement management with rigourous analysis to enable rational and objective decision-making processes, are an integral part of intelligence-led policing. Despite the prevalence of these assessments, as the assessments and their methodologies are often tightly restricted within the law enforcement community, it is often unclear how law enforcement defines, analyses and makes decisions about organised crime. While the use of risk assessment methodology to analyse organised crime in policing is generally under-evaluated, critics point to serious methodological weaknesses. Another aspect that is less explored in the scholarly literature is how law enforcement conceptualises and measures the impact or ‘harm’ from organised crime and uses this analysis to inform priority-setting processes. This article explores how law enforcement assess organised crime-related harm by examining five policing methods — one each from Australia and the Netherlands and three from the United Kingdom. The article finds that the methods have significant shortcomings: the main concepts are generally ill-defined and the operationalisation of these concepts is problematic. More importantly, the problems evident in the harm methods raise several critical questions, specifically whether measuring organised crime-related harms is empirically feasible and, if so, can be undertaken in a manner that meaningfully informs law enforcement’s decision-making and limits undue political interference.

Keywords: organised crime, organized crime, harm, risk, priority setting

Suggested Citation

Tusikov, Natasha, Measuring Organised Crime-Related Harms: Exploring Five Policing Methods (October 1, 2011). Crime Law and Social Change, November 2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1978182

Natasha Tusikov (Contact Author)

Baldy Centre, State University of Buffalo (SUNY)

SUNY Buffalo Law School
511 O'Brian Hall
Buffalo, NY 14201
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
174
Rank
145,825
Abstract Views
672