Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Double-Edged Paring Knives Human Rights Dilemmas for Special Populations

5 Pages Posted: 8 Feb 2012 Last revised: 1 Feb 2015

Giovanna Shay

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Date Written: 2011


The United States makes up only 5 percent of the world's population, but it incarcerates 25 percent of the globe's prisoners. This unprecedented level of incarceration has brought increased attention to the problems of particular subsets of prisoners sometimes called "special populations." These groups include female prisoners; lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender (LGBT), and questioning inmates; older prisoners; and prisoners with mental illness and physical disabilities. This Article discusses human rights dilemmas in the treatment of special populations in prison.

The Article surveys ABA Standards and Resolutions that bear on special populations. While ABA Standards do not have the force of law, they can serve as models for jurisdictions seeking to enact best practices, and as a resource for advocates.

Standards governing the management of special populations may be necessary to ensure humane treatment and avoid victimization and loss of life. However, they can be controversial, even among human rights advocates. There are two types of critiques: that reforms perpetuate stigma and stereotypes and that reforms reinforce our reliance on prisons. These controversies expose tensions regarding the role of prison conditions reform in the vast American corrections system.

The economic crisis may be pointing us toward new solutions to these dilemmas. There is a push to reduce incarceration-related expenses by reducing harsh sentences, even in some states that are traditionally tough on crime. Reducing the number of U.S. prisoners will provide the most lasting resolution to the human rights issues.

Keywords: prisoner's rights, incarcerated women, LGBT prisoners, lesbian prisoners, gay prisoners, bisexual prisoners, transgender prisoners, Brown v. Plata, Amador v. Andrews, criminal law, human rights law

Suggested Citation

Shay, Giovanna, Double-Edged Paring Knives Human Rights Dilemmas for Special Populations (2011). Human Rights, Vol. 38, No. 3, p. 17, Summer 2011; Western New England University School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 12-3. Available at SSRN:

Giovanna E. Shay (Contact Author)

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views