Does Trading Remove or Bring Frictions?
26 Pages Posted: 12 Mar 2012 Last revised: 3 Dec 2013
Date Written: August 29, 2011
Abstract
We explore in this paper how trading noise, when considered as a market friction, reacts to trading activity. Transactions cost is a good explanation for intraday trading behavior in the market according to our data. Particularly, we show that in general trading brings friction to market. However, trading friction at market open is the lowest during the day, as trading causes less friction then relatively. This is due to the behavioral difference among investors. When market opens, individual trading removes, while institutional trading brings, market friction. Situation in the rest of the day is just the opposite, where individual, instead of institutional, trading brings friction. The uneven behavior of trading noise across investors and time of day makes it a specific, rather than general, transactions cost, as opposed to Stoll (2000). Intraday trading activity suppresses both order width and depth, as proxies for trading intensity, therefore creates more noise or friction in the market. Width and depth contribute to trading noise in a polarized way, so that individual trading hurts friction in small cap stocks at open, but benefits it at close. Institutional trading brings extremely strong friction to large cap stocks, but less so at market close. So trading noise as a specific, rather than general, transactions cost is prominent only to certain investors, at certain time and for certain stocks in the market. Our findings lend itself to the justification of the new financial transactions tax proposed by the European Union.
Keywords: noise, transaction cost, herding, search model, order book
JEL Classification: C14, D82, D83, G12, L11
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Tick Size, Order Handling Rules, and Trading Costs
By Kee H. Chung and Chairat Chuwonganant
-
Tick Size, Order Handling Rules, and Trading Costs
By Kee H. Chung and Chairat Chuwonganant
-
Liquidity and Quote Clustering in a Market with Multiple Tick Sizes
By Kee H. Chung, Kenneth Kim, ...
-
A Simple Estimate of Noise and its Determinant in a Call Auction Market
-
An Empirical Analysis of Strategic Behaviour Models
By Carole Comerton-forde, Michael A O'brien, ...
-
Search Costs and Investor Trading Activity: Evidences from Limit Order Book
By William T. Lin, Shih-chuan Tsai, ...
-
Can Sub-Penny Pricing Reduce Trading Costs?
By Bidisha Chakrabarty and Kee H. Chung
-
Information Asymmetry, Bid-Ask Spreads and Option Returns
By Fredrik Berchtold and Lars L. Norden