Forthcoming Washington and Lee Law Review (2013)
44 Pages Posted: 29 Mar 2012 Last revised: 22 Apr 2012
Date Written: March 29, 2012
In a criminal system that tips heavily to the side of wealth and power, we routinely detain the accused in often horrifying conditions, confined in jails while still maintaining the presumption of innocence. Here, in the rotting jail cells of impoverished defendants, are the Shadowlands of Justice, where the lack of criminal procedure has produced a darkness unrelieved by much scrutiny or concern on the part of the law.
This article contends that our current system of pretrial detention lies in shambles, routinely incarcerating the accused in horrifying conditions often far worse than those convicted offenders existing in prisons. Due to these punitive conditions of incarceration, pretrial detainees appear to have a cognizable claim for the denial of their Sixth Amendment jury trial right, which, at its broadest, forbids punishment for any crime unless a cross-section of the offender’s community adjudicates his crime and finds him guilty. This article argues that the spirit of the Sixth Amendment jury trial right might apply to many pretrial detainees, due to both the punishment-like conditions of their incarceration and the unfair procedures surrounding bail grants, denials and revocations. In so arguing, I expose some of the worst abuses of current procedures surrounding bail and jail in both federal and state systems. Additionally, I also propose some much needed reforms in the pretrial release world, including better oversight of the surety bond system, reducing prison overcrowding by increasing electronic bail surveillance and revising the bail hearing procedure to permit a community “bail jury” to help decide the defendant’s danger to the community.
Keywords: pretrial detention, punishment, Sixth Amendment, bail, jail, incarceration
JEL Classification: K14
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Appleman, Laura I, Justice in the Shadowlands: Pretrial Detention, Punishment, and the Sixth Amendment (March 29, 2012). Forthcoming Washington and Lee Law Review (2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2031196 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2031196