Mobilising Collaborative Opportunities between Pension Funds

111 Pages Posted: 3 Apr 2012

See all articles by Danyelle Jann Guyatt

Danyelle Jann Guyatt

Climate Insight Pty Ltd; UN PRME Working Group on Sustainability Mindset; University of Bath

Date Written: May 2, 2007


Many collaborative initiatives amongst pension funds and their agents have emerged over recent years in an attempt to improve the workings of the market mechanism, most of which have been targeted at changing corporate, rather than investor behaviour. It has been argued that more consideration needs to be given to the development of collaborative initiatives that specifically target investor behaviour to overcome the problems of short-termism, absence of shareholder activism and poor pension fund governance standards.

This research paper develops a theoretical framework and applies this to identify the conventions associated with each investment problem, the target agents for change, the power agents and their inter-relationships.

The analysis reveals that, despite the significant number of collaborative initiatives that have been established, there are many areas that remain overlooked. For example, whilst some initiatives have emerged to tackle short-termism, these still do not directly confront the problems of excessive reliance on asset-based benchmarks and the short-term criteria used to select and review fund manager performance. On the goal of increasing shareholder activism, a number of collaborative initiatives have emerged but these tend to be regional in focus and narrow in their membership base, with no effort to establish international collaboration and standards in shareholder activism. Finally, improving pension fund governance is the grey area that most collaborative arrangements fail to address and there is a need to mobilise regulators and industry bodies to develop better standards.

Suggested Citation

Guyatt, Danyelle Jann, Mobilising Collaborative Opportunities between Pension Funds (May 2, 2007). Available at SSRN: or

Danyelle Jann Guyatt (Contact Author)

Climate Insight Pty Ltd ( email )

Melbourne, Victoria 3000

UN PRME Working Group on Sustainability Mindset

United Kingdom

University of Bath ( email )

Claverton Down
Bath, BA2 7AY
United Kingdom

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics