Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

To Drink the Cup of Fury: Funeral Picketing, Public Discourse and the First Amendment

76 Pages Posted: 9 Apr 2012 Last revised: 10 Nov 2012

Steven J. Heyman

Chicago-Kent College of Law - Illinois Institute of Technology

Date Written: November 9, 2012

Abstract

In Snyder v. Phelps, the Supreme Court ruled that the Westboro Baptist Church had a First Amendment right to picket the funeral of a young soldier killed in Iraq. This decision reinforces a view that has become increasingly dominant in First Amendment jurisprudence — the view that the state may not regulate public discourse to protect individuals from emotional or dignitary injury. This Article contends that this view not only sacrifices the law’s protections for individual personality but also undermines the normative foundations of public discourse itself. The Article then presents an alternative theory of the First Amendment which holds that the same values of human dignity and autonomy that support free speech also give rise to other fundamental rights. Thus, speakers should have a duty to respect the personality and rights of others. Drawing extensively on the record in Snyder as well as on other materials, the Article argues that Westboro’s funeral picketing should not receive First Amendment protection, for the picketing is intended to condemn the deceased and to inflict severe distress on the mourners in violation of their rights to privacy, dignity, emotional well-being, and religious liberty. Finally, the Article shows that although Westboro prevailed in Snyder, this may prove to be a Pyrrhic victory, for the Court also suggested that states can protect mourners through carefully drawn buffer-zone laws.

Keywords: free speech, free expression, rights, dignity, personality, privacy, Westboro, funeral, picketing, Supreme Court, public discourse, emotional distress, dignitary harm, death, buffer zone, Holmes, marketplace of ideas, tort, religion

JEL Classification: K10, K13

Suggested Citation

Heyman, Steven J., To Drink the Cup of Fury: Funeral Picketing, Public Discourse and the First Amendment (November 9, 2012). Connecticut Law Review, Vol. 45, No. 1, 2012 . Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2035916

Steven J. Heyman (Contact Author)

Chicago-Kent College of Law - Illinois Institute of Technology ( email )

565 W. Adams St.
Chicago, IL 60661-3691
United States
312-906-5228 (Phone)
312-906-5280 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
111
Rank
210,008
Abstract Views
929