Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Constitutionalizing Immigration Law: The Vital Role of Judicial Discretion in the Removal of Lawful Permanent Residents

64 Pages Posted: 12 Jun 2012  

Maritza Reyes

Florida A&M University College of Law

Date Written: June 1, 2012

Abstract

For decades, scholars and advocates criticized the harsh, mandatory nature of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines. They argued that federal district court judges should have discretion to authorize a punishment that fits the facts and circumstances of the crime and the defendant. Similarly, immigration scholars and advocates criticize the harsh laws that categorically remove lawful permanent residents, even after minor crimes, from the United States. In 2005, in United States v. Booker, the Supreme Court “constitutionalized” the Sentencing Guidelines by rendering them advisory, and returning judicial discretion to federal judges.

This Article argues that the similar constitutional, historical, theoretical, societal, and humanitarian policy considerations underlying sentencing and removal support the return of judicial discretion to the removal proceedings of longtime lawful permanent residents. By returning judicial discretion, Congress and the President would “constitutionalize” the deportation process rather than wait for Supreme Court action. The Article concludes with a proposal for legislative reform: “The Longtime Lawful Permanent Residents and Family Unit Relief Act.”

Keywords: immigration, Booker, constitutional, plenary power, Padilla, Arizona, deportation, removal, racism, criminal law, crimmigration, sentencing, immigration judges, lawful permanent residents, aliens, judicial discretion, IIRIRA, Federal Sentencing Guidelines, AEDPA, removal statistics

JEL Classification: I31, J15, J18, J71, J78, K14, K33, K42

Suggested Citation

Reyes, Maritza, Constitutionalizing Immigration Law: The Vital Role of Judicial Discretion in the Removal of Lawful Permanent Residents (June 1, 2012). Temple Law Review, Vol. 84, No. 3, 2012. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2082051

Maritza Reyes (Contact Author)

Florida A&M University College of Law ( email )

201 Beggs Avenue
Orlando, FL 32801
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
126
Rank
191,049
Abstract Views
1,195