The First Year of 'Say on Pay' Under Dodd-Frank: An Empirical Analysis and Look Forward
James F. Cotter
Wake Forest University School of Business
Alan R. Palmiter
Wake Forest University - School of Law
Randall S. Thomas
Vanderbilt University - Law School; European Corporate Governance Institute (ECGI)
February 17, 2013
George Washington Law Review, Vol. 81, No. 3, 2013
Vanderbilt Law and Economics Research Paper No. 12-32
Wake Forest Univ. Legal Studies Paper No. 2220259
Using voting data from the first year of “say on pay” votes under Dodd-Frank, we look at the patterns of shareholder voting in advisory votes on executive pay. Consistent with the more limited “say on pay” voting before Dodd-Frank, we find that shareholders in the first year under Dodd-Frank gave generally broad support to management pay packages. But not all pay packages received strong shareholder support. At some companies, management suffered the embarrassment of failed “say on pay” votes – that is, less than 50% of their company’s shareholders voted in favor of the proposal. In particular, we find that poorly-performing companies with high levels of “excess” executive pay, low total shareholder return, and negative ISS voting recommendations experienced greater shareholder “against” votes than at other firms.
Although “say on pay” votes are non-binding and corporate boards need not take action even if the proposal fails, most companies receiving negative ISS recommendations or experiencing low levels of “say on pay” support undertook additional communication with shareholders or made changes to their pay practices – reflecting a shift in the management-shareholder dynamic. During 2012, the second year of “say on pay” under Dodd-Frank, we find similar patterns, with companies responding proactively to an unfavorable ISS recommendation or a prior failed (or even weak) “say on pay” vote in 2011. We use four case studies to illustrate this new corporate governance dynamic, which we view as an important consequence of the Dodd-Frank Act.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 46
Keywords: Say on Pay, Dodd-Frank, Empirical, ISS
Date posted: October 19, 2012 ; Last revised: May 10, 2013