The 4 Percent Rule is Not Safe in a Low-Yield World

15 Pages Posted: 16 Jan 2013 Last revised: 17 Jan 2013

See all articles by Michael S. Finke

Michael S. Finke

The American College

Wade D. Pfau

The American College for Financial Services; McLean Asset Management

David Blanchett

Morningstar Investment Management

Date Written: January 15, 2013

Abstract

The safety of a 4% initial withdrawal strategy depends on asset return assumptions. Using historical averages to guide simulations for failure rates for retirees spending an inflation-adjusted 4% of retirement date assets over 30 years results in an estimated failure rate of about 6%. This modest projected failure rate rises sharply if real returns decline. As of January 2013, intermediate-term real interest rates are about 4% less than their historical average. Calibrating bond returns to the January 2013 real yields offered on 5-year TIPS, while maintaining the historical equity premium, causes the projected failure rate for retirement account withdrawals to jump to 57%. The 4% rule cannot be treated as a safe initial withdrawal rate in today’s low interest rate environment. Some planners may wish to assume that today’s low interest rates are an aberration and that higher real interest rates will return in the medium-term horizon. Although there is little evidence to support this assumption, we estimate how a reversion to historical real yields will impact failure rates. Because of sequence of returns risk, portfolio withdrawals can cause the events in early retirement to have a disproportionate effect on the sustainability of an income strategy. We simulate failure rates if today's bond rates return to their historical average after either 5 or 10 years and find that failure rates are much higher (18% and 32%, respectively for a 50% stock allocation) than many retirees may be willing to accept. The success of the 4% rule in the U.S. may be an historical anomaly, and clients may wish to consider their retirement income strategies more broadly than relying solely on systematic withdrawals from a volatile portfolio.

Keywords: retirement, systematic withdrawals, 4% rule, safe withdrawal rates

JEL Classification: C15, D14, G11, G17

Suggested Citation

Finke, Michael S. and Pfau, Wade D. and Blanchett, David, The 4 Percent Rule is Not Safe in a Low-Yield World (January 15, 2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2201323 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2201323

Michael S. Finke

The American College ( email )

Bryn Mawr, PA 19010
United States

Wade D. Pfau (Contact Author)

The American College for Financial Services ( email )

630 Allendale Rd
King of Prussia, PA 19406
United States

HOME PAGE: http://www.retirementresearcher.com

McLean Asset Management ( email )

1900 Gallows Rd, Suite 350
# 1150
Vienna, VA 22182
United States

David Blanchett

Morningstar Investment Management ( email )

22 W Washington
Chicago, IL 60602
United States
859-492-5637 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.davidmblanchett.com

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
8,252
Abstract Views
31,322
rank
675
PlumX Metrics