A Situational Approach to Incapacity and Mental Disability in Sexual Assault Law

27 Pages Posted: 18 Jan 2013 Last revised: 13 Mar 2014

See all articles by Janine Benedet

Janine Benedet

University of British Columbia - Faculty of Law

Isabel Grant

University of British Columbia - Faculty of Law

Date Written: 2013

Abstract

Prosecutions for sexual assault most often focus on whether the Crown has proven that the complainant did not consent to the sexual activity in issue, based on her subjective state of mind at the time of the offence. However, Canadian criminal law also provides that no consent is obtained where the complainant is incapable of consenting. In cases where the complainant has a mental disability affecting cognition or decisionmaking, prosecutors in Canada have been reluctant to argue that the complainant was incapable of consenting. In this article, the authors agree that claims of incapacity should be used sparingly, but contend that the doctrine of incapacity may be applicable and useful in some cases where the accused has exploited the complainant’s disability. They argue that capacity to consent to sexual activity should be defined situationally, rather than as an all-or-nothing measure. Since consent is given to a specific person in a specific circumstance, incapacity should be also assessed by reference to the particular context of the case. This approach to incapacity has been adopted in English and American cases, which provide examples of how it might be applied and understood in Canada. A situational definition of incapacity offers some legal recognition of the particular challenges faced by women with mental disabilities with respect to sexual abuse, without disqualifying them from any lawful sexual activity in other contexts.

Keywords: Canada, Criminal law, Consent, Capacity, Incapacity, Equality, Mental disability, Sexual assault

Suggested Citation

Benedet, Janine and Grant, Isabel, A Situational Approach to Incapacity and Mental Disability in Sexual Assault Law (2013). (2013) 43:1 Ottawa Law Review 1-27, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2201883 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2201883

Janine Benedet

University of British Columbia - Faculty of Law ( email )

1822 East Mall
Vancouver, British Columbia V6T 1Z1
Canada
604 822 0637 (Phone)
604 822 8108 (Fax)

Isabel Grant (Contact Author)

University of British Columbia - Faculty of Law ( email )

1822 East Mall
Vancouver, British Columbia V6T 1Z1
Canada

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
147
Abstract Views
986
rank
237,341
PlumX Metrics