Are Catholic Bishops Seeking a Religious Preference or Religious Freedom?

Ivan E. Bodensteiner

Valparaiso University Law School

February 2013

Valparaiso University Legal Studies Research Paper No. 13-1

This Article questions whether religious institutions have become too aggressive in seeking preferences for themselves, often at the expense of the freedom of their members. In Hosanna Tabor, the Court recognized a "ministerial exception," based on the First Amendment, for religious organizations when sued by certain employees or former employees alleging a violation of a federal statute prohibiting discrimination in employment and retaliation against those who seek to enforce such a statute, or assist others in doing so.

Shortly after the decision in Hosanna Tabor, the Catholic Bishops orchestrated a series of lawsuits challenging a provision of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act that requires most employer health insurance plans to provide certain essential health benefits, including "[p]reventive and wellness services," as required by Guidelines issued by Health Resources and Services Administration. The Catholic institutions pursuing these cases argue that the challenged provisions violate their religious freedom, protected by both the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment and a federal statute, because the mandated benefit includes birth control, the use of which Catholic doctrine prohibits. As in Hosanna Tabor, the institutions are asking the courts to provide them with a preference that trumps the freedom of their members.

In my view, the institutions involved in these two situations are showing a callous disregard for the well-being of their employees where laws designed to promote equality and freedom have, at most, a marginal effect on the religious freedom of the institutions.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 34

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: February 6, 2013  

Suggested Citation

Bodensteiner, Ivan E., Are Catholic Bishops Seeking a Religious Preference or Religious Freedom? (February 2013). Valparaiso University Legal Studies Research Paper No. 13-1. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2209772 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2209772

Contact Information

Ivan E. Bodensteiner (Contact Author)
Valparaiso University Law School ( email )
656 S. Greenwich St.
Valparaiso, IN 46383-6493
United States
Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 360
Downloads: 56
Download Rank: 288,343