Book Review: William J. Stuntz, The Collapse of American Criminal Justice

Journal of Legal Education, Vol. 62, p. 377, 2012

UC Berkeley Public Law Research Paper No. 2239799

11 Pages Posted: 27 Mar 2013  

Andrea L. Roth

University of California, Berkeley - School of Law

Date Written: November 1, 2012

Abstract

One of the better ways to celebrate next year’s fiftieth anniversary of Gideon v. Wainwright, in which the Supreme Court held that poor defendants accused of felonies in state court are constitutionally entitled to appointed counsel, would be to force every lawmaker, judge, prosecutor, and defense attorney in the United States to read the last major work of a man who believed the legacy of Gideon is not an unequivocally positive one. In The Collapse of American Criminal Justice, the late Bill Stuntz argues that the cure for the pathologies of the criminal justice system lies in restoring local democratic control over crime policy, better funding public defenders, and buttressing equal protection doctrine, rather than in the continued focus on the “vast network of procedural rules the Supreme Court has crafted since the early 1960s." Stuntz argues that the fetishization of so many formalistic procedures that, in his view, at best indirectly ensure fairness of trial and sentencing outcomes has rendered trials too expensive, which in turn has driven prosecutors and lawmakers to seek ways to avoid trial and force pleas through draconian sentencing schemes, a skewed focus on easily detected urban drug crimes mostly committed by racial minorities, and ever-expanding substantive criminal law. The result of this assembly-line justice, Stuntz argues, is both excessive punitiveness in the form of racially disparate mass incarceration and excessive leniency in the form of underprosecuted violent crime in poor communities.

Suggested Citation

Roth, Andrea L., Book Review: William J. Stuntz, The Collapse of American Criminal Justice (November 1, 2012). Journal of Legal Education, Vol. 62, p. 377, 2012; UC Berkeley Public Law Research Paper No. 2239799. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2239799

Andrea L. Roth (Contact Author)

University of California, Berkeley - School of Law ( email )

215 Boalt Hall
Berkeley, CA 94720-7200
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
117
Rank
195,122
Abstract Views
740