Indian Tribes and Human Rights Accountability

61 Pages Posted: 30 Mar 2013

See all articles by Wenona T. Singel

Wenona T. Singel

Michigan State University College of Law

Date Written: 2012

Abstract

In Indian country, the expansion of self-governance, the growth of the gaming industry, and the increasing interdependence of Indian and non-Indian communities have intensified concern about the possible abuse of power by tribal governments. As tribes gain greater political and economic clout on the world stage, expectations have risen regarding the need for greater government accountability in Indian country. Despite these expectations, Indian tribes are largely immune from external accountability with respect to human rights. In fact, tribes have effectively slipped into a gap in the global system of human rights responsibility. The gap exists in the sense that tribal governments are not externally accountable in any broad sense for abuses of human rights that they commit. The failure of the legal system to provide for tribal accountability for human rights produces serious harms for Indian tribes and their polities. In this Article, I argue that the conventional understanding of tribal sovereignty must be reformed to reflect the transformative international law principle that all sovereigns are externally accountable for human rights violations. I then offer a proposal based on tribal accountability and respect for tribal sovereignty. I propose that tribes develop an intertribal human rights regime that includes the formation of an intertribal treaty recognizing tribal human rights obligations and establishing an intertribal institution with the capacity to enforce human rights violations. An intertribal human rights regime offers the best possible method for providing external accountability for tribal abuses of human rights. It allows tribes to address human rights violations without relying upon solutions supplied or imposed by the federal government. It also allows tribes to articulate and interpret universal human rights in light of their cultural, philosophical, spiritual, political, and social perspectives, and it allows them to develop effective and culturally appropriate institutional enforcement mechanisms.

Keywords: Indian tribes, human rights, tribal courts, tribal lawmaking, tribal treaty rights, United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, tribal membership, disenrollments

Suggested Citation

Singel, Wenona T., Indian Tribes and Human Rights Accountability (2012). San Diego Law Review, Vol. 49, 2012; MSU Legal Studies Research Paper No. 11-01. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2241017

Wenona T. Singel (Contact Author)

Michigan State University College of Law ( email )

318 Law College Building
East Lansing, MI 48824-1300
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
338
rank
85,158
Abstract Views
2,082
PlumX Metrics