Commandeering Information (and Informing the Commandeered)

16 Pages Posted: 4 Apr 2013

See all articles by Anthony Johnstone

Anthony Johnstone

University of Montana School of Law

Date Written: March 25, 2013

Abstract

In Can the States Keep Secrets from the Federal Government? Robert Mikos offers an important contribution to the scholarly discussion of state departures from federal policies by presenting two novel insights. First, Professor Mikos recognizes that information exchanged between federal and state governments is an expanding ground for conflict between federal and state policy spheres. Second, he observes that federal demands for state-gathered information are formally and functionally indistinguishable from other forms of prohibited commandeering. Both of these points will reverberate in future conversations about federalism, and I could not attempt to exhaust their implications here.

Instead, my Response will amplify and extend Professor Mikos’s first point, which identifies the commandeering problem, and will suggest some limits to his second point, which proposes a judicially managed solution. Commandeering information should be recognized, like other forms of federal coercion of state officials, as imposing significant costs on states. Yet the costs to state autonomy from commandeering information, and the prospects that federal judges might mitigate them, are (as they are for commandeering generally) relatively limited. Further, the costs to political accountability from commandeering information are difficult to assess, but these may be more effectively mitigated through political means. Even if Professor Mikos’s conception of commandeering information is not enforced by the Judiciary, it at least helps the states (and their citizens) recognize that they have been commandeered.

Keywords: Federalism, Tenth Amendment, commandeering, anti-commandeering, information, Printz v. United States, New York v. United States

Suggested Citation

Johnstone, Anthony, Commandeering Information (and Informing the Commandeered) (March 25, 2013). University of Pennsylvania Law Review Online, Vol. 161 p. 205. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2244191

Anthony Johnstone (Contact Author)

University of Montana School of Law ( email )

Missoula, MT 59812-0002
United States

HOME PAGE: http://www.umt.edu/LAW/

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
26
Abstract Views
939
PlumX Metrics