How International Courts Enhance Their Legitimacy

14 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 455 (2013)

The Hebrew University of Jerusalem ILF Research Paper No. 04-13

25 Pages Posted: 21 Apr 2013 Last revised: 2 Sep 2015

See all articles by Shai Dothan

Shai Dothan

University of Copenhagen - iCourts - Centre of Excellence for International Courts

Date Written: August 13, 2013

Abstract

International courts strive to enhance their legitimacy, that is, they would like the members of the international community to perceive their judgments as just, correct and unbiased even if they do not agree with their specific content. This Article argues that international courts take into account the actors they interact with, the norms they apply, and the conditions they operate under as they try to enhance their legitimacy. It demonstrates strategic behavior towards that end in the judgments of two prominent international courts — the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). International courts interact with states under their jurisdiction and with their national courts. International courts try to preserve their legitimacy vis-à-vis states; at the same time, they want to signal that states will comply with them even if they issue judgments states disagree with. International courts can cooperate with national courts and gain legitimacy from interacting with legitimate national courts. The norms that international courts apply constrain their ability to maneuver their judgments in ways that can help their legitimacy, but at the same time help legitimize their judgments. International courts use various tactics to shape their reasoning in order to improve their legitimacy. The behavior of international courts is scrutinized by the domestic public within each state. That public has certain agendas, priorities and preferences. The domestic public's agenda is a condition that the court must respond to, but sometimes courts can also shape that agenda to their benefit.

Keywords: European Court of Human Rights, International Court of Justice, Judicial Behavior, Legitimacy

Suggested Citation

Dothan, Shai, How International Courts Enhance Their Legitimacy (August 13, 2013). 14 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 455 (2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2250971 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2250971

Shai Dothan (Contact Author)

University of Copenhagen - iCourts - Centre of Excellence for International Courts ( email )

Studiestraede 6
Copenhagen, DK-1455
Denmark

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
211
rank
137,382
Abstract Views
1,537
PlumX Metrics