Reclaiming Equality to Reframe Indigent Defense Reform

72 Pages Posted: 17 Apr 2013

See all articles by Lauren Sudeall

Lauren Sudeall

Vanderbilt University - Vanderbilt Law School

Date Written: April 17, 2013


Equal access to resources is fundamental to meaningful legal representation, yet for decades, equality arguments have been ignored in litigating indigent defense reform. At a time when underfunded indigent defense systems across the country are failing to provide indigent defendants with adequate representation, the question of resources is even more critical. Traditionally, advocates seeking indigent defense reform have relied on Sixth Amendment arguments to protect the rights of indigents in this context; however, the Sixth Amendment approach suffers from a number of shortcomings that have made it a poor tool for systemic reform, including its exclusive focus on attorney performance and its inability to directly address issues of underfunding or to prospectively set substantive standards for indigent defense representation.

This Article argues that the reincorporation of equality principles - rooted in the fundamental right of access to the courts - into indigent defense reform can address some of the doctrinal gaps left by the more traditional Sixth Amendment approach and provide a conceptual framework that targets the root causes of systemic indigent defense failures. An approach grounded in equal access and not solely on the vindication of the right to counsel allows reformers to: attack issues of resource allocation directly without filtering them through the lens of attorney conduct, reach resource inequities beyond the provision of counsel, prospectively define substantive elements of a meaningful defense, and clear a more direct path to necessary normative judgments about what those elements must be. The choice to reclaim equality as a basis for indigent defense reform recognizes that unequal access to resources precludes the enforcement of substantive rights and forces a decision between the commitment to access for justice to all or only for those who can afford it.

Keywords: Sixth Amendment, Right to Counsel, Equal Protection, Equality, Indigent Defense, Criminal Procedure

Suggested Citation

Sudeall, Lauren, Reclaiming Equality to Reframe Indigent Defense Reform (April 17, 2013). Minnesota Law Review, Vol. 97, No. 4, p. 1197, 2013, Georgia State University College of Law, Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2013-12, Available at SSRN:

Lauren Sudeall (Contact Author)

Vanderbilt University - Vanderbilt Law School ( email )

131 21st Avenue South
Nashville, TN 37203
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics