From the Police Precinct to Your Neighbor's Coffee Table: Limiting Public Dissemination of Mug Shots During an Ongoing Criminal Proceeding Under the Freedom of Information Act

39 Pages Posted: 24 Apr 2013  

Whitney T. Martin

University of Iowa - College of Law

Date Written: April 23, 2013

Abstract

The Freedom of Information Act provides for public access to government agency records. Agencies have discretion, however, to withhold any information that falls under one of the Act’s exemptions, including, in some instances, private individual records. While the Supreme Court has recognized that criminal detainees have a privacy interest in restricted dissemination of their criminal records, it has yet to rule on whether the same privacy interest exists in mug shots. Currently, there is a circuit split over this issue. This Note analyzes the split in light of the purpose and history of the Freedom of Information Act, and argues that future courts that entertain the issue should adopt the reasoning employed by the Tenth Circuit — namely, recognizing a privacy right in detainees’ mug shots in ongoing criminal proceedings. The Supreme Court has already recognized the detrimental and lasting stigma on the not-yet convicted detainee. In holding that such a privacy interest exists, the Court will maintain consistency in tending towards increased privacy protection under the Act, minimize negative stigma, and still adhere to the Act’s purpose.

Keywords: Freedom of Information Act, FOIA, circuit split, mug shots, unwarranted invasion of privacy, privacy interest, public interest, dissemination, privacy exemptions, criminal detainee, balancing test, government agency, exemption 7(C), rap sheets, ongoing criminal proceeding, stigmatizing effect

JEL Classification: K14, K23

Suggested Citation

Martin, Whitney T., From the Police Precinct to Your Neighbor's Coffee Table: Limiting Public Dissemination of Mug Shots During an Ongoing Criminal Proceeding Under the Freedom of Information Act (April 23, 2013). Iowa Law Review, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2255694 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2255694

Whitney T. Martin (Contact Author)

University of Iowa - College of Law ( email )

Melrose and Byington
Iowa City, IA 52242
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
47
Abstract Views
465