Justice Holmes and Conservatism

10 Pages Posted: 23 Jul 2013  

Allen Mendenhall

Faulkner University Thomas Goode Jones School of Law

Date Written: 2013

Abstract

Conservatives and libertarians have been harsh critics of Justice Holmes, but Holmes was not the progressive that these critics make him out to be. Holmes’s jurisprudence lends itself to conservative and libertarian jurisprudence, in particular in the areas of federalism and judicial restraint. Holmes disdained the politics of the young socialists who adored him, and Richard Posner goes so far as to cast Holmes as a free market capitalist. A common mistake is to take Holmes’s deference to the mores and traditions of states and localities as evidence of his shared belief in those mores and traditions. Holmes did not have to agree with states and localities to say that federal judges and Supreme Court justices should not inject their worldview into the life of a local community with an opposing worldview. The pragmatist in Holmes disliked making decisions that were not rooted in lived experience or based on observable, concrete phenomena relating to commonplace interactions among regular people. Holmes also disliked any tendency to marry morality and law, since law, for him, was a set of rules reflecting the practical consequences arising out of everyday social relations. All labels for Holmes miss the mark. Holmes defies categorization, which is a lazy way of affixing a name to something to avoid considering the complexity and nuances and even contradictions inherent in that something. Although defying labels, Holmes does offer views that conservatives and libertarians ought to prize, not criticize.

Keywords: Justice Holmes, Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., Conservatism, William James, Libertarianism, Judicial Restraint, Federalism, The Fourteenth Amendment, Pragmatism

Suggested Citation

Mendenhall, Allen, Justice Holmes and Conservatism (2013). Texas Review of Law & Politics, Vol. 17, No. 2. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2296865

Allen Mendenhall (Contact Author)

Faulkner University Thomas Goode Jones School of Law ( email )

The Blackstone Center for Law & Liberty
Faulkner Law, 5345 Atlanta Highway
Montgomery, AL United States of America 36109
United States
334-386-7495 (Phone)
334-386-7505 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://AllenMendenhall.com

Paper statistics

Downloads
45
Abstract Views
246