Everyman's Exclusionary Rule: The Exclusionary Rule and the Rule of Law (or Why Conservatives Should Embrace the Exclusionary Rule)

31 Pages Posted: 7 Aug 2013 Last revised: 14 Aug 2013

See all articles by Scott E. Sundby

Scott E. Sundby

University of Miami School of Law

Date Written: August 5, 2013

Abstract

It should come as little surprise that the exclusionary rule has been the continual target of strong criticism for a very long time. The rule appears to run head-on into a basic principle of justice learned as early as one’s playground days: "Two wrongs don’t make a right." Justice Cardozo expressed the same sentiment in one of the most famous judicial lines ever penned, "The criminal is to go free because the constable has blundered." Far more of a surprise, then, given such an entrenched critique from a variety of quarters, is that the exclusionary rule has continued to remain a centerpiece of Fourth Amendment jurisprudence for almost a century. The rule’s lengthy reign suggests that the exclusionary rule, like its critique, also draws upon some basic wellspring of justice. This Essay searches for that wellspring and argues that when rule-of-law principles are used as the prism through which the exclusionary rule is viewed, the exclusionary rule’s fundamental value to our criminal justice system becomes far more compelling. By returning the focus from the Court’s current view of the exclusionary rule as a ‘punishment’ or ‘deterrent’ for individual law enforcement officials back to the rule’s original role as a critical linchpin in preserving the Constitution’s structural limitations on government power, we can begin to make far greater sense of the rule’s longevity and understand the importance of the exclusionary rule for the future.

Suggested Citation

Sundby, Scott E., Everyman's Exclusionary Rule: The Exclusionary Rule and the Rule of Law (or Why Conservatives Should Embrace the Exclusionary Rule) (August 5, 2013). Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, Vol. 10, No. 2, Spring 2013. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2306157

Scott E. Sundby (Contact Author)

University of Miami School of Law ( email )

1311 Miller Dr.
Coral Gables, FL 33146
United States
305-284-5848 (Phone)

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
102
Abstract Views
527
rank
261,852
PlumX Metrics