Resolving the Dilemma of Legal Parentage for Australians Engaged in International Surrogacy

(2013) 27(2) Australian Journal of Family Law

36 Pages Posted: 21 Aug 2013  

Jenni Millbank

University of Technology, Sydney, Faculty of Law

Date Written: August 19, 2013

Abstract

The Australian approach to legal parentage is particularly complex in the context of trans-national surrogacy arrangements. Australian law does not generally recognise parental status granted in other jurisdictions and overseas commercial surrogacy arrangements are excluded from specifically enacted domestic surrogacy laws that enable transfer of legal parentage in certain circumstances. Thus Australian administrators and judges have had to grapple with the claims of Australians trying to return with a foreign born child with whom they usually have a genetic link and a primary caregiving role, but no legal relationship. Recognition has occurred through ad hoc liberalisation of interpretations of ‘parent’ and ‘child’ in particular pieces of legislation, which has left parents in a state of ambiguous, labyrinthine and ‘limping’ legal parentage. This article presents an analysis of the problems posed by the current lacunae before going on to explore the risks and potentiality of possible reforms to federal law. The analysis in this article is informed throughout by my own view of surrogacy as a valid method of family formation which should be respected. The State has a legitimate objective in trying to ensure that surrogacy is undertaken with the informed and continuing consent of all the parties, and most particularly the surrogate, given the unique impact and significance of the gestational relationship. This must be balanced with the need to accord certainty of parental status to children being raised in surrogacy families.

Keywords: surrogacy, assisted reproduction, legal parentage, international surrogacy

JEL Classification: K19, K33

Suggested Citation

Millbank, Jenni, Resolving the Dilemma of Legal Parentage for Australians Engaged in International Surrogacy (August 19, 2013). (2013) 27(2) Australian Journal of Family Law . Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2312830

Jenni Millbank (Contact Author)

University of Technology, Sydney, Faculty of Law ( email )

Australia

Paper statistics

Downloads
300
Rank
81,108
Abstract Views
1,003