Bringing Justice to Environmental Assessment: An Examination of Kearl Oil Sands Joint Review Panel and the Health Concerns of the Community of Fort Chipewyan

Journal of Environmental Law and Practice, Vol. 21, pp. 31-64 (2010)

34 Pages Posted: 23 Aug 2013

See all articles by Nathalie J. Chalifour

Nathalie J. Chalifour

University of Ottawa - Common Law Section

Date Written: 2010

Abstract

Environmental assessment is a critical tool for helping to reduce the environmental impacts of development projects. However, the process as currently designed and implemented does little to ensure that the environmental harms created are fairly distributed among members of the public. Using the human health concerns raised by the community of Fort Chipewyan in the wake of massive oil sands developments upstream as a case study, this paper argues that the Kearl Oil Sands environmental assessment process did little to promote social justice for this community. While the environmental assessment process created an avenue for the community to share its concerns, the process failed to protect against the possibility that these concerns, once voiced, would simply be discounted or marginalized in the determination of what is a “significant environmental adverse effect (SAEE)”. I argue that the duty to apply the precautionary principle now explicitly embodied within CEAA creates a reverse onus upon project proponents to show that their proposal will not create SAEEs and suggest it should be interpreted to include a duty to demonstrate that the environmental harms deemed acceptable will not be shouldered disproportionately by an under-privileged community. I propose a number of reforms that could help transform environmental assessment into a process that promotes environmental justice. To critics who suggest that project-level assessment is not the place to address environmental justice, I argue that environmental assessment processes must not be a mechanism for perpetuating existing systemic inequalities by condoning an unfair distribution of environmental harm. Bringing the question of the distribution of environmental benefits and burdens to the forefront of assessments will lead to greater justice for all.

Keywords: environmental justice, environmental assessment, precautionary principle, equality, oil sands, Aboriginal communities, Fort Chipewyan

Suggested Citation

Chalifour, Nathalie, Bringing Justice to Environmental Assessment: An Examination of Kearl Oil Sands Joint Review Panel and the Health Concerns of the Community of Fort Chipewyan (2010). Journal of Environmental Law and Practice, Vol. 21, pp. 31-64 (2010) . Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2314598

Nathalie Chalifour (Contact Author)

University of Ottawa - Common Law Section ( email )

57 Louis Pasteur Street
Ottawa, K1N 6N5
Canada

HOME PAGE: http://www.uottawa.ca

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
82
rank
287,063
Abstract Views
431
PlumX Metrics