Unreasonable Search and Seizure & Section 8 of the Charter: Cost-Benefit Analysis in Constitutional Interpretation

Errol Mendes and Stéphane Beaulac, eds. Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, 5th ed. (Toronto: Lexis, 2013), Forthcoming

56 Pages Posted: 5 Sep 2013

See all articles by Steven Penney

Steven Penney

University of Alberta - Faculty of Law

Date Written: September 4, 2013

Abstract

In this Chapter, the author describes and critiques the Supreme Court of Canada’s section 8 jurisprudence (which has generally been analyzed in doctrinal and deontological terms) through the lens of cost-benefit analysis. This approach involves two basic inquiries. In the first, the specific private and social costs and benefits of extending (or not extending) particular privacy protections in particular circumstances are identified. This cannot be done in a quantitative, formulaic, or technocratic fashion. Moral and political value judgments are unavoidable, and jurists will continue to disagree about reasoning and outcomes. But greater rigour and precision would (at a minimum) make the balancing process more transparent and (potentially) narrow the range of disagreement. The second inquiry involves the question of institutional capacity; that is, whether courts or legislatures are better equipped to regulate state intrusions into privacy in a particular realm. Legislatures and courts operate with differing incentives, biases, and information deficits. Greater awareness of these differences should help courts to avoid becoming more deeply involved in regulating privacy intrusions than their institutional capacities warrant. This methodology is then applied to explain and critique the two key elements of section 8: the definition of a "search or seizure" and the assessment of "reasonableness".

Keywords: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, charter, search and seizure, section 8, cost-benefit analysis, law and economics, public choice, constitutional interpretation

JEL Classification: D80, K00, K14

Suggested Citation

Penney, Steven, Unreasonable Search and Seizure & Section 8 of the Charter: Cost-Benefit Analysis in Constitutional Interpretation (September 4, 2013). Errol Mendes and Stéphane Beaulac, eds. Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, 5th ed. (Toronto: Lexis, 2013), Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2320634

Steven Penney (Contact Author)

University of Alberta - Faculty of Law ( email )

Law Centre
University of Alberta
Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2H5
Canada

HOME PAGE: http://www.ualberta.ca/law/faculty-and-research/profiles/steven-penney

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
171
Abstract Views
1,034
rank
200,210
PlumX Metrics