Manufactured Inconsistency

25 Pages Posted: 6 Oct 2015

See all articles by Nicolas Dour

Nicolas Dour

Independent

Greg Taylor

University of Adelaide - School of Law; University of Marburg; RMIT University - Graduate School of Business and Law

Date Written: September 12, 2013

Abstract

Manufactured inconsistency under s 109 of the Constitution has had little attention devoted to it. This article undertakes a detailed consideration of manufactured inconsistency in two important respects. First, the principle of manufactured inconsistency is analysed in order to derive a definitional understanding of the term beyond the vague description that the Commonwealth may not ‘create’, ‘ fabricate’ or ‘manufacture’ an inconsistency. This article argues that the key to manufactured inconsistency lies in the concept of bad faith in legislating, whereby bad faith is evident where Commonwealth legislation is directed against the states’ capacity to legislate rather than enacted for any reason of policy. The concepts of good faith and bad faith in constitutional law are then analysed in order to identify indicia that might establish manufactured inconsistency. This leads to the conclusion that the actual intention of the Commonwealth is central to determining manufactured inconsistency, and principles of legislative intent and legislative motive are also considered. Second, this article considers whether there is any basis for implying such a doctrine into constitutional law under the requirements set out in Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation for drawing implications. While there is limited support for the implication, it is contended that manufactured inconsistency should not develop as a separate body of doctrine, but should instead fall within the Melbourne Corporation principle because manufacturing an inconsistency with state laws can properly be characterised as destroying the states’ capacity to govern.

Keywords: Australian Constitutional Law, inconsistency

JEL Classification: K39

Suggested Citation

Dour, Nicolas and Taylor, Greg, Manufactured Inconsistency (September 12, 2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2325164 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2325164

Nicolas Dour

Independent ( email )

Greg Taylor (Contact Author)

University of Adelaide - School of Law ( email )

Ligertwood Building
Adelaide 5005, South Australia SA 5005
Australia

University of Marburg ( email )

Universitätsstrasse 24
Marburg, D-35032
Germany

RMIT University - Graduate School of Business and Law ( email )

Melbourne
Australia

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
31
Abstract Views
277
PlumX Metrics