Criminal Procedure -- Habeas Corpus -- Ninth Circuit Holds That the Supreme Court's Decision in Ring v Arizona Applies Retroactively to Cases on Habeas Corpus Review -- Summerlin v Stewart, 341 F3d 1082 (9th Cir 2003) (En Banc)

8 Pages Posted: 12 Oct 2013 Last revised: 15 Oct 2013

See all articles by Neel U. Sukhatme

Neel U. Sukhatme

Georgetown University Law Center; Georgetown McCourt School of Public Policy

Date Written: February 1, 2004

Abstract

In Ring v. Arizona, the Supreme Court held that the Sixth Amendment requires a jury, not a judge, to find the aggravating factors necessary to impose a capital sentence. Recently, in Summerlin v. Stewart, an en banc panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that Ring announced a substantive rule that applies retroactively to cases on federal habeas review -- a judgment that directly conflicts with the Eleventh Circuit's decision in Turner v. Crosby. Although the Summerlin court reached the right result, it relied on tenuous distinctions between procedural and substantive law, as well as ambiguous studies about the differences between jury and judge fact-finding. Instead, the court should have based its decision solely on the Supreme Court's continuous emphasis on the jury's important role in expressing the moral judgment of the community in capital cases.

Keywords: capital punishment, fact-finding, procedural, substantive, retroactivity, harmless error, Summerlin v. Stewart, Ring v. Arizona, Apprendi v. New Jersey, Teague v. Lane

Suggested Citation

Sukhatme, Neel U., Criminal Procedure -- Habeas Corpus -- Ninth Circuit Holds That the Supreme Court's Decision in Ring v Arizona Applies Retroactively to Cases on Habeas Corpus Review -- Summerlin v Stewart, 341 F3d 1082 (9th Cir 2003) (En Banc) (February 1, 2004). Harvard Law Review, Vol. 117, No. 4, p. 1291-98, 2004. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2338193

Neel U. Sukhatme (Contact Author)

Georgetown University Law Center ( email )

600 New Jersey Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20001
United States

Georgetown McCourt School of Public Policy ( email )

Old North, Suite 100
37th & O Streets NW
Washington, DC 20057
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
11
Abstract Views
243
PlumX Metrics