Reconciling Different Legal Spheres in Theory and Practice: Pluralism and Constitutionalism in the Cases of Al Jedda, Ahmed and Nada

20.2 Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 2013, pages 218‐240

35 Pages Posted: 20 Oct 2013

See all articles by Christina Eckes

Christina Eckes

Amsterdam Centre for European Law and Governance

Stephan Hollenberg

Utrecht University

Date Written: October 19, 2013

Abstract

A detailed analysis of four judicial responses to extreme pluri-contextual settings, the House of Lords’ and the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)’s rulings in Al-Jedda, the UK Supreme Court’s judgment in Ahmed, and the ECtHR’s recent ruling in Nada, demonstrates that all three courts relied on elements of pluralist and constitutionalist logic. Elements of institutional hierarchy in international law are balanced against considerations that can be understood as substantive constitutional concerns. Sometimes their effects are counteracted by blunt pluralist claims. Radical pluralism and state-like constitutionalism are the two extreme poles on one scale. Both are ideal types and cannot exist in their pure form. The analysis further confirms the increased power of the judiciary, which, when determining the applicable normative framework, ultimately makes a choice between competing authorities representing competing values. ‘Communicative’ pluralism may contribute to the emergence of a shared frame of reference and ultimately to a shared understanding of the importance of certain substantive values.

Suggested Citation

Eckes, Christina and Hollenberg, Stephan, Reconciling Different Legal Spheres in Theory and Practice: Pluralism and Constitutionalism in the Cases of Al Jedda, Ahmed and Nada (October 19, 2013). 20.2 Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 2013, pages 218‐240, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2342516

Christina Eckes (Contact Author)

Amsterdam Centre for European Law and Governance ( email )

Oudemanhuispoort 4-6
1012 CN Amsterdam
Netherlands

Stephan Hollenberg

Utrecht University ( email )

Vredenburg 138
Utrecht, 3511 BG
Netherlands

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
67
Abstract Views
371
rank
398,711
PlumX Metrics