How Does the New York Constitution Compare the U.S. Constitution?
28 Pages Posted: 15 Nov 2013 Last revised: 19 Nov 2013
Date Written: 1998
One of the most interesting, and certainly most litigated, defamation questions in New York State is when constitutional protection should be afforded speech that arguably would be regarded as opinion. In resolving that question, the New York Court of Appeals has decided that the New York State Constitution affords greater protection for speech than does the federal constitution. While the New York standard seems to be far more generous in protecting speech than the federal standard, it may be that in the vast majority of cases, the outcomes would be the same under either state or federal analysis. The two standards use different routes to get to more or less the same place. Both standards ultimately focus on whether a reasonable reader would understand the statement to be asserting a fact about the plaintiff.
Keywords: freedom of speech, defamation, New York State Constitution, Federal Constitution, First Amendment
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation