Rules as Icons: Wittgenstein's Paradox and the Law

22 Pages Posted: 13 Nov 2013

See all articles by Bert van Roermund

Bert van Roermund

Tilburg Law School; Tilburg School of Humanities - Tilburg Law School -

Date Written: December 2013

Abstract

In this paper Section 1 distinguishes between two modes of interpreting legal rules: rehearsal and discourse, arguing that the former takes priority over the latter in law, as in many other contexts. Section 2 offers two arguments that following a legal rule in the rehearsing mode presents a riddle. The first argument develops from law, and submits that legal rules do not tell us anything, because they are tautological. The second one develops from philosophy (Wittgenstein's later works), confronting us with the paradox that incompatible courses of action may be derived from any rule. My solution presents a theory of rules as icons (Section 3). I use “icon” rather than “picture,” partly to avoid confusion with what is known among philosophers as “the picture theory of meaning.” Interpretation in the rehearsing mode hinges on imagination: imagining oneself in the space of reasons for action rather than reasoning oneself. In this act of imagination, we project ourselves into the rule in ways that are similar to the way we grasp the sense of paintings, music, stories, or poems. Finally (Section 4) I will defend the position that my view solves the puzzles in the second section, by arguing (a) that it is a better account of what Wittgenstein wrote than two competing theories (intuitionism and conventionalism), and (b) that it provides a more satisfactory account of how lawyers deal with legal rules in actual practice.

Suggested Citation

van Roermund, Bert, Rules as Icons: Wittgenstein's Paradox and the Law (December 2013). Ratio Juris, Vol. 26, Issue 4, pp. 538-559, 2013. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2353654 or http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/raju.12027

Bert Van Roermund (Contact Author)

Tilburg Law School ( email )

PO Box 90153
Tilburg, 5000 LE
Netherlands

Tilburg School of Humanities - Tilburg Law School - ( email )

Postbus 90153
Tilburg, DC 5000 LE
Netherlands
+31 13 466 2510 (Phone)
(013) 466 2892 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.tilburguniversity.edu/about-tilburg-university/schools/humanities/philosophyoflaw/

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
0
Abstract Views
339
PlumX Metrics