The Court-Packing Plan as Symptom, Casualty, and Cause of Gridlock

19 Pages Posted: 15 Nov 2013

Date Written: November 15, 2013

Abstract

This essay, prepared for the Notre Dame Law Review's Symposium, “The American Congress: Legal Implications of Gridlock,” considers three ways in which President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s 1937 Court-packing bill was related to the phenomenon of gridlock in the 1930s. First, as FDR's public remarks on the subject demonstrate, he believed that the early New Deal was a victim of partisan gridlock between the Democrat-controlled political branches and the Republican-controlled judiciary. Moreover, he did not believe that the impasse could be overcome through an amendment to the Constitution, for he regarded Article V's supermajority requirements as virtually encoding gridlock into the amendment process. The Court-packing bill was thus a response to that interbranch gridlock. Second, the bill was itself a casualty of gridlock within Congress owing to two institutional features of that body: the committee system, and the Senate filibuster. Third, the Court-packing fight helped to cement a bi-partisan anti-New Deal coalition in Congress that mobilized to frustrate much of the President's second-term agenda, resulting in gridlock between the President and Congress. The Court-packing controversy thus managed, in a single, high-profile episode, to present in sharp relief and in a variety of configurations the gridlock-related implications of several features of our political and constitutional system.

Keywords: Franklin D. Roosevelt, Court-Packing Plan, Supreme Court, Hatton Sumners, Henry Fountain Ashurst, William Borah, Burton Wheeler, Homer Cummings, Joseph Robinson, Charles Evan Hughes

Suggested Citation

Cushman, Barry, The Court-Packing Plan as Symptom, Casualty, and Cause of Gridlock (November 15, 2013). Notre Dame Law Review, Vol. 88:5, 2013; Notre Dame Legal Studies Paper No. 1460. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2355080

Barry Cushman (Contact Author)

Notre Dame Law School ( email )

P.O. Box 780
Notre Dame, IN 46556-0780
United States

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
62
Abstract Views
758
rank
363,824
PlumX Metrics