Conundrums in Assisted Reproduction

Whittier Law Review, Vol. 21, pp. 451-460, 1999

Posted: 11 Aug 2000

Abstract

Increasing numbers of couples are pursuing in vitro fertilization, leading to an ever-growing supply of cryopreserved embryos. When these couples divorce, the courts are faced with a new type of property dispute: who gets the frozen embryos.

While courts could decide these disputes using a best-interests analysis, they have chosen not to. Instead, courts adopt one of two models. The first, a privacy rights model, weighs the right to procreate versus the right to avoid procreation. Courts adopting this model have held that the right to avoid procreation should ordinarily trump, unless the party seeking to procreate has no other reasonable possibility of achieving parenthood. In the second model, the courts seek to enforce the couple's intent, as expressed in the dispositional agreement they have signed.

This essay argues that the courts have employed both the privacy rights and contractual models in result-oriented ways. Courts uniformly favor the party seeking to avoid procreation. To avoid facilitating the creation of post-divorce, single-parent families, the courts have embraced unsupported constitutional presumptions and skewed contractual readings. This essay concludes that the conundrum that remains in frozen embryo disputes is: will courts ultimately enforce dispositional agreements in good faith or will they continue toward results- oriented jurisprudence - a jurisprudence that avoids the creation of single-parent families and favors the right to avoid parentage over the right to secure it?

Suggested Citation

Waldman, Ellen, Conundrums in Assisted Reproduction. Whittier Law Review, Vol. 21, pp. 451-460, 1999. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=235859

Ellen Waldman (Contact Author)

Thomas Jefferson School of Law ( email )

701 B Street
Suite 110
San Diego, CA 92101
United States
619-961-4346 (Phone)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
485
PlumX Metrics