Conceptual Metaphors for an Unfinished Constitution

Abstract

This paper argues that Canadian constitutional culture relies on a general narrative, that the Canadian Constitution is unfinished; a series of conceptual metaphors instantiate this narrative. Each conceptual metaphor frames different conditions — which may or may not be consistent — to justify constitutional practices. Understanding the justifying logic at play gives us the key to a more meaningful comparison between Canadian judicial constitution-making and other forms of constitution-making, both within Canada or in other constitutional orders.

Keywords: Constitutional Law, Constitutional Cultures, Conceptual Metaphors, Narratives, Judicial Constitution-Making, Canada