Genealogical Analysis of Islamic Law Books Relied on in the Courts of Pakistan
Al-Adwa December 2013
13 Pages Posted: 5 Feb 2014 Last revised: 11 Feb 2017
Date Written: December 31, 2013
The legal cum judicial system in Pakistan is dual in its character which was erected as such in the colonial period by British government of the Indian Subcontinent. The courts in Pakistan decide cases on the basis of the enacted laws, but when they do not find any enacted law particularly in matters of Personal law they apply the Islamic law provided the parties to the suit are Muslims. This arrangement begs an important question: which books are relied upon by the courts for ascertaining the Islamic legal principles. This paper aims to respond this important question. The paper traces the genealogy of such books and attempts to explore how they have attained such a privileged status despite the fact that there are other authentic works on Islamic law available in market. The authors have carried out an exploratory exercise first to determine which books are more frequently referred to by the courts. On the basis of such an exercise, the paper carries out a genealogical analysis of some of the most important books considering the fact that a full-fledged analysis of the entire source material would not be possible within the space of a single paper.
Keywords: Islamic Law; British India; Judicial System; Pakistan; Supreme Court; High Court; Personal Law; Colonial India; Indian Subcontinent
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation