Private Enforcement of Competition Law and Stand-Alone Actions in Hungary

SZILÁGYI PÁL: Private Enforcement of Competition Law and Stand-alone Actions in Hungary. Global Competition Litigation Review, (6) 2013/3, 13 -142.

7 Pages Posted: 17 Feb 2014  

Pál Szilágyi

Competition Law Research Centre; Péter Pázmány Catholic University

Date Written: February 16, 2014

Abstract

In this article I evaluate the available case law (16 cases) on the private enforcement of Hungarian and EU competition rules in stand-alone actions. Before 1st of November 2005 it was not clear whether it was possible to initiate stand-alone actions based on Articles 11 (anticompetitive agreements) and 21 (abuse of a dominant position) of the Hungarian Competition Act (HCA). The courts interpreted the law in a way which in their opinion prevented the direct application of competition rules by the courts. The law was therefore amended in November 2005 and the HCA directly allows for private actions.

In recent years the number of reported cases grew, but basically all of them were either unfounded or frivolous. In most of the cases the parties were just trying to invoke every legal norm which might aid them and somehow they found that the wording of the HCA might be useful. In most of the cases it turned out that relying on the HCA had no merits at all. Most of the judgements are either not discussing the competition issues at all, or only reflect to the arguments of the parties briefly. Only some cases go into the details and have a meaningful discussion of the provisions of the HCA and whether they are applicable or not. The article depicts a very unsatisfactory situation and provides a thorough overview of the recent case law.

Keywords: private enforcement, stand-alone actions, Hungary

JEL Classification: K21, L40, K42

Suggested Citation

Szilágyi, Pál, Private Enforcement of Competition Law and Stand-Alone Actions in Hungary (February 16, 2014). SZILÁGYI PÁL: Private Enforcement of Competition Law and Stand-alone Actions in Hungary. Global Competition Litigation Review, (6) 2013/3, 13 -142.. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2396802

Pál Szilágyi (Contact Author)

Competition Law Research Centre ( email )

PPKE-JAK
Szentkiralyi u. 28.
Budapest, H-1088
Hungary

HOME PAGE: http://www.versenyjog.com

Péter Pázmány Catholic University ( email )

Szentkirályi u. 28.
Budapest, 1088
Hungary

HOME PAGE: http://www.jak.ppke.hu

Paper statistics

Downloads
101
Rank
217,301
Abstract Views
476