Measuring Independence: Approaches, Limitations, and a New Ranking Tool

In: The Independence of the Media and Its Regulatory Agencies. Shedding New Light on Formal and Actual Independence Against the National Context, W. Schulz, P. Valcke & K. Irion (eds.), Bristol UK/ Chicago USA: Intellect 2013, p. 139-184.

35 Pages Posted: 15 Apr 2014

See all articles by Kristina Irion

Kristina Irion

University of Amsterdam

Michelle Ledger

Cullen International

Date Written: October 14, 2013

Abstract

It is the starting point of this chapter that there is no accepted methodology to measure the formal and de facto independence of independent regulatory authorities, even if some progress has been made in this field, and that empirical research on the subject, consequently, is scarce and very fragmented. To the extent that they exist at all, studies tend to concentrate on measuring formal independence, since specific legal provisions can be identified and assessed much more easily than the de facto expression of independence. This chapter will introduce the different approaches to measuring formal and de facto independence that have been proposed and critically reflect their potential and limitations, especially for comparative research. Two aspects specific to the audiovisual media sector are particularly relevant in this respect:

1. the objective of regulation in the media sector to guarantee media freedoms and

2. the specific and sometimes sensitive relationship between the media sector and the public authorities (i.e. the media as ‘fourth state power’).

Subsequently, this chapter introduces a ranking tool which has been developed specifically to measure the risk of influence by external players, rather than one to measure the level of independence of the regulators themselves. This enables a more objective method for ranking the indicators. The ranking approach follows the overall distinction between formal and de facto indicators. The methodology will be described and the use of the ranking tool will be illustrated.

Keywords: independent regulatory authorities, independence, formal independence, de facto indepedence, composite index, ranking tool

Suggested Citation

Irion, Kristina and Ledger, Michelle, Measuring Independence: Approaches, Limitations, and a New Ranking Tool (October 14, 2013). In: The Independence of the Media and Its Regulatory Agencies. Shedding New Light on Formal and Actual Independence Against the National Context, W. Schulz, P. Valcke & K. Irion (eds.), Bristol UK/ Chicago USA: Intellect 2013, p. 139-184., Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2424711

Kristina Irion (Contact Author)

University of Amsterdam ( email )

Rokin 84
Amsterdam, 1012 KX
Netherlands

Michelle Ledger

Cullen International ( email )

Clos Lucien Outers 11-21/1
Brussels, 1160
Belgium

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
58
Abstract Views
544
rank
438,595
PlumX Metrics