Methodological Stare Decisis and Constitutional Interpretation

Precedent in the United States Supreme Court (Christopher J. Peters, ed., 2013)

Marquette Law School Legal Studies Paper No. 14-11

25 Pages Posted: 26 Apr 2014

Date Written: 2013

Abstract

This chapter assesses the Supreme Court's reluctance to give stare decisis effect to its methodologies of constitutional interpretation. While the Court claims to presumptively follow the substantive results of its prior constitutional decisions, it has never considered itself bound by the interpretive approaches (e.g., originalism, textualism, or "living constitutionalism") used to reach those decisions. The chapter suggests an explanation for this somewhat mysterious state of affairs. A rule of methodological stare decisis would require the Court to employ the same interpretive method in a huge category of cases (most likely all cases involving the Constitution), which would generate unpredictable results in many cases the Court could not reasonably anticipate, thus aggravating the drawbacks of stare decisis. At the same time, the usual benefits of stare decisis (such as predictability and stability) would not be well served. Where the Court can reasonably follow its methodological precedent is with respect to "decision rules" -- methods, such as the tiered scrutiny framework, for implementing rather than determining constitutional meaning -- because those rules are relatively determinate and can be contained within narrowly defined areas of substantive doctrine.

Keywords: stare decisis, methodogical stare decisis, interpretation, constitutional theory, interpretive methodology

JEL Classification: K1, K4

Suggested Citation

Oldfather, Chad M., Methodological Stare Decisis and Constitutional Interpretation (2013). Precedent in the United States Supreme Court (Christopher J. Peters, ed., 2013); Marquette Law School Legal Studies Paper No. 14-11. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2428962

Chad M. Oldfather (Contact Author)

Marquette University - Law School ( email )

Eckstein Hall
P.O. Box 1881
Milwaukee, WI 53201
United States
414.288.8031 (Phone)

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
104
Abstract Views
742
rank
259,836
PlumX Metrics